Friday, December 11, 2009

HW 29- Merchants of Cool

Should advertising to young people be banned?
As I write this, I struggle to find a side to choose on the hot-topic of whether advertising to young people should be banned. On one hand, I say that it is wrong, that young people should be able to progress at their own rate and decide what they want to spend their money on. However, on the other hand I feel that advertising is unavoidable and even if consciously stopped, it will happen on another level. On yet another hand, I feel that young people are such a vital part of the economy that things would not be stable without them being targeted. By the end of this though, I will choose my side and lay down my allegiances.
Before I start on the main arguments, let's look at what advertising is by definition. "The act or practice of calling public attention to one's product, service, need, etc., especially by paid announcements in newspapers and magazines, over radio or television, on billboards, etc." (Dictionary.com). In my own words, it is the act of drawing attention to something through announcements. Keep this in mind.
"Teens are like Africa" (48 seconds into the first part). Hearing that said, so matter-of-factually is something that is quite unsettling. If you are of African heritage, or even not, you know what has happened when rich men in suits refer to Africa, seeing vast resources and opportunities but leaving the people ravaged. If teenagers are then like Africa, what does this say about what happens once they reach 20, and are no longer the target audience? They cannot think for their own and become fractured shells of beings, unable to function as they once were. Later another spokesman for an advertising agency says that "If you don't understand and recognize, what they're thinking and what they're feeling, you're going to lose, you're absolutely going to lose" (53 seconds into the first part). I'm sorry, are teenagers a game now? Are we suddenly the competition that you have to conquer over? Impersonal statements like this also leave you wondering whether all of these higher-ups actually care or even realize what they are doing to teenagers. In case you are seeking an answer, they don't care.
However, advertising is impossible to stop. Look at Britney Spears. Her music is not an ad., telling you to buy some product, it is instead a product itself with side effects of altered ideals. With her video Baby One More Time she is projecting a story that she can't bear to be alone, advertising the ideal of a couple. However, different interpretations of the lyrics can make it seem alright for girls to stay in abusive relationships because they really like the person. Songs like this also project the ideal of beauty. This therefore encourages the\at people invest in products that will make them prettier. And there is your ad right there, coming from a non-advertising source, one that cannot be altered as it is a deep-rooted part of the culture an changing it would be perceived as unconstitutional. Proof that, even without billboards and commercials, advertising cannot be stopped through mediums such as music, but on a larger level, word of mouth.
In many ways though, it would be irresponsible to stop advertising for young people if it were possible. Teenagers are responsible for anywhere between 100 and 150 billion dollars of our economy every year (3 minutes and 23 seconds into the first part). Now, say you remove the advertising, what do they spend their money on? That is what the marketing agencies of America want you to wonder. Granted, what would eventually happen would be a decrease in profit and in general sales, because kids would either not spend the money or they wouldn't receive it. As a result, the economy would dip, with major agencies having to restructure their companies. Also, even in this situation, the advertising would be focused towards the youngest audience they could approach, and this would trickle down through word of mouth. The only way to rid this effect would be to get rid of all advertising and word of mouth, which would destroy the economy.
All in all, I feel like the best way to approach advertising is to get rid of it. Let the product advertise itself. Companies spend upwards of $20,000 just to see what teenagers think is cool, when in reality they could just spend some money on interviewing kids to see what they think is cool. Over-exposure is never seen as cool, so this would make the products cooler as well. If companies focus on making a better product with all of this leftover money, they would end up with a larger profit and all in all a more stable and long-lasting appeal.

Sunday, December 6, 2009

HW 28- Informal Research- Internet, Magazines, and TV shows

The guide to "cool" can be found on nearly every website. While often generic, AskMen.com had something not surprising but still unique to a degree. The first part of being cool, have a nice girlfriend. The article then expanded and including things like "being called more than you call" and "having a purpose when you call, not just to talk". Later, the article said "be scarce", alluding to not always being available. If you are always available for somebody you will be seen as "needy".
On a more emotional level, the article suggests that in order to be seen as "cool" one must not broadcast their weaknesses and should associate with "cool" people. If you bring losers to the group, you are seen as a loser, so bring cool people and be seen as cool. Lastly, don't ever "lose your cool", a.k.a. don't get angry or frustrated, because nobody wants to see you get all riled up, man.

Be Cool

This guide on how to be cool does not specify towards men, like the AskMen.com guide, but rather it approaches both genders on an equal playing field. The guide begins with not caring about what other people think of you. However, step two is "Be aware of how others will perceive you". The guide approaches this contradiction by acknowledging the difference between letting opinions affect your self esteem and being aware of how you come off to others.
The guide then has other generic statements like "Don't be afraid to be different" and "find real friends".
My favorite part of this guide to cool was the seventh guideline, "Learn how to laugh at yourself". This is a personal favorite of mine and it is something that you rarely see in person and you almost never see acknowledged. The guide says that doing so humanizes you, which is true, but it also shows you know you aren't perfect, which I feel is even more important.


The was not so much of a guide as an answer to somebody's question online. The question being "How do you turn from geek to cool?" The answer that was posted was surprisingly heartfelt and real for an online generic answer. The answerer stated that you don't need to change who you are to be cool, claiming that you can be a geek and still be cool.
However, in this answer their impression of what is cool came through, mainly being popular and being social. While somebody can be into anime and video games and things typically labeled as geeky, they can still be seen as cool if they are social and wear make-up and do their hair. While this raises questions, I will leave it for now.

How to be cool- AlanWho.com
Lastly we have Alan Who's perspective on how to be cool. This guide starts with telling you in the first guideline that you are already cool, despite what everybody told you. He then lists how to be cool. The article should stop, because what guidelines could I possibly need if I am already cool? Regardless, the following guidelines cover everything from posture to social interactions, with Alan Who stating that you should stand tall and upright and that you should never lose your temper and should use you own lingo instead of yo and ight and later. I thought that this latter suggestion was good and I had not seen it anywhere else, but it makes logical sense that if you are cool you start trends and don't participate.
My favorite part of this guide was that the last guideline said you are constantly learning. Those not learning are busy dying, as the article says. I thought that this was a very cool perspective to see and I had never thought about where learning fit into a larger opinion of cool outside of my own. I thought that this was refreshing and shows that intelligence is in fact valued in some circles.

Bibliography
  • WikiHow. December 7, 2009
  • "How do you turn from Geek to Cool?". Wiki.Answers. December 7, 2009 <http://wiki.answers.com/Q/How_do_you_turn_from_geek_to_cool>

  • Who, Alan. "How to Be Cool". AlanWho.com. December 7, 2009
  • Bayer, Jeff. "Be Cool". AskMen.com. December 7, 2009

Thursday, December 3, 2009

HW 27- Informal Research- Interviews and Surveys

Family member-

Me: Do you think that tabloids are cool?
Family member: Yes.
Me: Why?
Family member: Because I think that that shit is funny.
Me: But would you say it is "cool"?
I think it's actually kind of pathetic, but I think that it's funny. I'm kind of a jerk (Laughs).
Me: Just to clarify, what is your definition of cool?
Family member: I hate this (Laughs again). Something that really kicks ass I guess. Somebody that isn't a wimp, somebody that just does whatever they want and they stick with their cause. I don't give a shit what anybody thinks and I think that makes somebody cool. They don't care if anybody follows them or not, they just do it anyways, I think that's cool.
Me: Going back, why do people live through celebrities?
Family member: People like to live through other people so they use to it to live a good life.
Me: Are children cool?
Family member: What does that mean? Some children are cool I guess. My children are cool (Laughs), but most kids are cool. But at the same time a lot of kids suck though. I think that it is too general to judge, some are good, some are bad, some are lame.
Me: Who is a cool celebrity? Or who is your favorite?
Family member: THE coolest celebrity... I have no idea (Laughs). Paris Hilton, Miley Cyrus (Laughs). Lady Gaga or Amy Winehouse. Because she is a train wreck and I love it. Kate Moss, David Bowie. I think they are pretty cool. Mick Jagger is really cool.
Me: Why are they cool?
Family member: Because none of them give a shit, they are all individuals and have their own style and aren't afraid to revel in it.
Me: Who did you think was cool when you were little?
Family member: Punky Bruster. Pippy Longstocking, Michael Jackson. They were really funky and they made me stop and pay attention, they stood out. I thought that was cool.

Street Interview 1-

Me: Are children cool?
Man with stroller: I think children are very cool, clearly (Laughs).
Me: Do you think that the mainstream media perceives children as cool?
Man with stroller: I don't really care. I think they're fun and that's all that matters to me.

Street Interview 2-

Me: Are tabloids cool?
British man: No, not at all.
Me: What do you think about the people that follow them so closely?
British man: I think poorly of them. They have a low I.Q.
Me: What about children, do you think they are cool?
British man: Yea, I suppose so, yes.
Me: Who is your favorite celebrity, or the celebrity you think is coolest?
British man: I don't have one. They are just human beings, people. Doesn't make them any cooler than anybody else.

Street Interview 3-

Me: I see that you are an animal lover, do you think that the media sees animal as cool?
Man with dog: Yes, they always seem to shine them in a pretty positive light.
Me: Do you think that kids are cool?
Man with dog: Well... no. I mean, not for me personally, I don't like kids that much.
Me: What do you think your family and friends would say?
Man with dog: They would think they are, they all pretty much like kids.

Monday, November 23, 2009

HW 26- Photos & Questions


Henry Guss, High Schooler
First off, some people say appearance is everything, so what would this say about you?
I am everything.
Do you ever see other people with this look when you're out and about?
No, I'm unique. Not really, nobody. Not many people are doing the button down shirt anymore.
How does that make you feel?
It makes me feel good, really good. I feel like an individual and different and not the same.
Would you say you're cool?
I'm quite warm actually. (Laughs) There's no such thing as cool.
What makes you say that?
Cool is whatever somebody makes it out to be and I make it out to be nothing.

Alex Simmons, Writer
So there is the old saying, appearance is everything. What would this say about you?
That I am a slob. (Laughs) I'm an easygoing kind of guy, I like to present myself well but I don't have to be fancy to do that.
Do you ever see other people with this look when you're out and about?
Yes, I do. There is what you call business casual and another level even, where people will wear a button down shirt unbuttoned with jeans when they work in computers or communications and don't have to worry about appearance as much.
How does that make you feel?
It doesn't bother me, I know who I am.
Would you say you're cool?
At times, I'm not perpetually cool nor do I think about being cool but there are times when yes, I think that I am cool. Cool is a state of mind and what I might think is cool, other people might disagree but I don't need their acceptance.
Do you think cool matters?
It's not really a yes or no question, it matters to some people but it shouldn't be how you judge yourself all the time, but it can be fun or it can be crippling if you let it overcome you and stop you from being who you are.

Name omitted, Art Student
First off, some people say appearance is everything, so what would this say about you?
Well, I think it's important not to look like a mess, because then people get a certain impression of you that may not be correct. appearance is how you project an image of yourself to the outside world, and I always keep that in mind when I get dressed in the morning. The way I look isnt precisely the way I want people to see me, but it's close enough.
What would make it precisely how you want people to see you?
Well it depends on the situation. Like on a casual level I wanna look laid back, but not like a slob, and put together but not too made up, if that makes sense. That reflects my general attitude but not really my 'inner self', mostly because my inner self is a huge freaking nerd.
Do you see other people with a similar look when you walk around?
Yeah, sometimes.
Do you care? How does it make you feel? Do you feel like you can connect more with them?
It doesn't really bother me. It's impossible to be entirely unique when it comes to clothes, and i don't really care unless people are looking at me and thinking "Oh my God HIPSTERRRRR" or whatever. Ugh, hipsters. I don't feel particularly like I connect with people based on appearance--mostly because I know I probably don't connect with them in terms of the way our minds work.
You mention "hipsters". What is it about them that annoys you? What would you call a hipster?
Hipsters. Pretentious, annoying, and nowhere near as intelligent or forward thinking as they think they are. The most irritating hipsters are the ones who have money yet insist on going to thrift stores and dressing themselves in secondhand clothes. They're a perfect example of people trying SO hard to be different that they just end up conforming.
So are you cool then?
(Snorts) Depends on your definition of cool. Am I conventionally cool, definitely not. Some people think I'm cool and a hell of a lot of people would say hell no.

Marco Gonzalez, Realist
Some people say appearance is everything, so what would this say about you?
I dress simply and efficiently to reflect who I am.
Is this a common look outside of yourself?
Not really, everybody seems to try to get a certain look but I choose my clothes based on how comfortable they are rather than how they look. I dress more for function than form.
Would you say that is a good way to summarize your mentalities in general?
Yes.
Would you be surprised to find this kind of function-first mentality in a more mainstream venue?
Yea. It’s easy to sell shiny shit, spin rims on cars for example, but it’s hard to sell something that just there to serve a purpose, and since corporations dictate what the mainstream says and shows they're going to display flashy pointless things that look nice but serve little to no purpose.
Do you think that the things the mainstream media promotes are cool then, by your own definition of the concept?
No, because things like skinny jeans may look cool but they're probably not that comfortable and wearing your pants "half-mast" can't be comfortable either, especially in winter so there's a lot of fads that may look nice but don't make sense logically to follow.
Do you think you are cool by your own definition?
To clarify, my definition of cool is someone who knows what they want to do, whether it's their purpose what they do for fun or whatever it may be. The attitude and “swagger will follow that”. By my definition I think I'm cool because I live my life the way I like it, I don't have to be an attention whore to be happy, I know what I like and don't like and I'm content with my life the way the it is, I don't need to dress it up in expensive shit to make it better.
Would the mainstream cool agree?
Probably not since I'm not dressed up in expensive clothes and I don't go to parties and get wasted or listen to mainstream music etc.


HW 25- Story Comments and Analysis

Part 1- Comments

Hannah-

Hannah, I liked your story. I felt like it was interesting to see how the girl thought she was cool and yet she tried to act cooler despite this. The boy complementing the girl and saving her is also pretty cool and I liked how you added in details such as the smell of his jacket.

Maggie-

Maggie, I like the simplicity of your story. Though you use no dialogue, you manage to convey a very surreal atmosphere that is like a waiting room of a hospital, with small talk and frantic personalities. I like how you convey cool by seeing through other people's fake faces and this is a common thread everybody is aware but rarely do you see this in the real world, which I think helped to add to the tone of the piece.

Rachel-

Rachel, I thought it was interesting that you pointed out bluntly what made her cool. I think that your story worked best when you led the reader to draw their own conclusions and left the girl a mystery. By having her ignore others and dismiss their opinions of her, I think that you made her seem like her own person, an individual, which is always cool. Adding in the copycats at the end was a nice touch to show the social impact she was having on the community and that others also thought she was cool.

Marco-

Marco, I found your story to really stand out amongst many of the ones I have read. Your more offensive look on what cool is helps to show that in fact, the narrator is the cool person, not those observed. By not selling out to some corporation to buy what's cool, you show that being true to who you are is cool. This is well supported by your talk of jocks and nerds and geeks, which I think was nice touch to show how cool is not one defined term and is different amongst different people.

Beatrice-

Beatrice, I found your story to be quite interesting. By having the girl simply isolate herself from everybody else, she has her individuality and that makes her much cooler than those around her who can't even work up the courage to talk to her. Music is very important here, because by ending and starting the story with music you show that Tatum is off in her own world, but a world of uncertainty and I think that this is an interesting thing to think about when one thinks of cool, how we can doubt ourselves or be unsure and still be cool. Good job.

Part 2- Analysis

Cool is not store bought, despite what the media would have you believe. Every story I read and even the one I wrote came to the realization that cool was in the way one acted, in their attitude. I think that this is a very key conclusion to come to, although it is a rather simple and obvious conclusion. If cool was truly store bought, why wasn't everybody cool? And if everybody did buy "cool" from the store, would it still be cool to have "cool"? No, cool is best when it comes from inside a person and they act like they don't care about anybody's opinion of themselves.
These stories all had another common theme amongst 4 of them, somewhat 5 depending on how you interpret Marco's story. This theme is that even if cool is not store bought, it can be enhanced. By having "cool" headphones or cool "jeans", somebody can have a "look" that makes them cooler. In the case of Hannah's story, the cool character fell into the category of bad boy/ladies man, even if not intentional. By having the "cool" character smooth talk and save the girl, he was also the typical hero of literature, saving the helpless damsel in distress. This is often seen as cool in many different representations. As for Rachel's story, by having the "cool" jeans and boots, the character was cool because she had copycats. While she was cool in addition to this, she was extra cool because of this.
I found it interesting that in none of the stories was anybody older cooler. I know the assignment was to discuss somebody around 17 years old who was cool, but nobody had any real interactions with older generations and none had anybody cool that was older than the protagonist. I think that while accidental, this does give insight in that people don't find older generations to be particularly cool. This is a pretty mainstream perspective and shows the effects of cool and the boundaries because nobody can maintain cool forever and nobody is cool in everybody's eyes, which connects to Marco's story about different groups of cool. All in all, cool is not all encompassing and is not eternal, but just something to fill the time between the actual meaningful activities of life.

Wednesday, November 18, 2009

Hw 24- Short Story 1

Have you ever seen an old western movie, where the cool new sherif comes in to a salon and takes names and kicks ass right from the get go? Yea, that's not the way High School works. The cool new sherif of our school didn't get over easily and didn't dominate from the beginning. Instead she walked into the classroom quietly, got introduced quickly by the teacher, and faded into nothing from the get-go.
I saw her in the back of the classroom, the green of her tank top complementing the purple of her mini-jacket, making her look the Joker fan-girl you knew she wasn't. Her jeans compressing her legs, she leaned back with her hand propped behind her head, a notebook out on the table with what seemed to be nothing more than just the Do-Now of the day and her heading. The teacher saw this too. I don't know if he saw this as an insult or a challenge, but whatever his reason, he called on her to answer the challenge problem on the subject he had just taught. The subject that the do-now didn't even talk about, so as far as I was concerned, she had no idea where to even start, explaining her lack of care in the goings-on.
I thought this was cold of him, to call on the new girl on the first day of advanced physics to go up to the board on a problem from a new subject everybody was struggling to complete. Eyes lifted from around the room as they watched her go up to the board. Not a word was uttered by her though. No angry retort that she had been called on, no whine that he was picking on the new kid, simple the tapping of her slight heels as she walked across the room to the board. She turned her back to us, wrote her answer, and sat down. Mouths slowly started to move again.
"Who is that?"
"I didn't even see her back there"
"Is that some college student here to learn how to teach?"
"I bet she doesn't even know the subject"
"This'll be interesting"
As the voices quieted, she chuckled to herself. I could tell she heard the voices, she didn't even care though. She went back to her former position at this point, as her own way of flipping everybody off. The teacher asked her to explain her answer, she told him simply and with an elegant flair like nobody else I had seen before, "I just did what you put on the board and used the formula's and wrote it down for you up there as I figured it out". He asked if she could explain it more than that and she said "Well I can't explain the way my mind works, all I know is that I was right and that you spelled his named wrong up there".
A hush over the room, all eyes stared at our teacher as he saw he had indeed misspelled it, and he went over how to solve the problem. Nobody looked back at her, but I had never stopped in the first place. She caught me looking at her and smiled a little smile, putting her head down to doodle in the void her notes would have inhabited if she hadn't already proved she didn't need any.

Monday, November 16, 2009

HW 23- 1st Constructivist Exploration of Cool

Cool is an interesting concept. It isn't something you can define properly or even hold onto for an extended period of time but it is something that most people recognize immediately. What is it about cool that is so easily accessible to everybody and yet so hard to maintain?
I think cool never really dies completely. Instead it fades from one group of people to another. For example, hippies were once very cool by mainstream society. They were everywhere you looked and they were the symbol of their times. They were in the mainstream grouping. However, as time progressed and people moved on with their lives and things changed, hippies left that group of people, being the mainstream, and moved on to form a smaller group of pure hippies that still exists today through the evolution of it's popularity. The same can be said about other concepts that expand past people as well. For example, in the 90's, Seinfeld was one of the top shows on TV and it was very cool to watch it and discuss it the next day. Now it has moved from this mainstream grouping into a lesser group of cool, the nostalgia group.
I think that cool is also dictated by the popular. I understand that this is not some grand new revelation, but those considered popular or cool do not take responsibility for their actions the way that they should. This changes the course of cool as well and makes it cool to be irresponsible and to not care about your actions. This is the general direction society has been heading in the last few years thanks to people like Amy Winehouse or Britney Spears who don't take care of anybody except for themselves, and even so they don't take tremendous care and often lead their lives into chaos. This is in right now and society heads down as a result.
Cool is not always about being popular and without a care though. Take for instance the 1986 hit song, "Hip to Be Square" by Huey Lewis and the News. This song is about being "square", or being a nerd. The song peaked at number 1 on the U.S. Billboard top rock tracks listings and reached number 3 in the overall U.S. Billboard category. With lyrics like "I used to be a renegade... but had to settle down" and "Now I'm playing it real straight", this song counters what makes most other songs popular and completely avoids what made other songs of the year such as "Addicted to Love" and "Greatest Love of All" so popular. This shows that cool isn't a constant, as I stated earlier, however it helps to establish a trend that can connect to today, such as love always being cool in some form, however where it was once the "Greatest Love of All" it is now "3". A very drastic change to be sure.

All links provided are via Youtube and may not be accessible through school connections.