Showing posts with label Partners. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Partners. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 20, 2010

HW 36- Triangle Partner Help

Maggie-

We are constantly trying to fill the void in our lives with attention and approval. If the media has shown us anything, it is that the kids that come from a broken home are often the coolest. Now, this is not always true, but if you look at movies like Spider-Man, you can see this often is the case. See, in Spider-Man, Peter Parker has a happy life with with Aunt and Uncle, and has almost no mayhem in his home life. He is of course, a nerd. On the contrary, his neighbor, Mary-Jane Watson, comes from a home with an abusive father and is shown to be very cool at school. This can be explained as having a larger void to fill. You see, Peter is happy and as such he feels no need to live his life in any way other than the path his family enforces. Since he doesn't really need to break away from his mold, he doesn't need to be cool and becomes a nerd. Mary-Jane on the other hand greatly feels this need to be cool because she is being given a destructive and highly negative path at home. Therefore, she acts out and tries to be "cool". This is a cry for both attention and approval, both of which she was denied at home, whereas Peter had them in surplus.
1- In you first argument, you use my cool story as a point of reference in summarizing a point. However, you misinterpreted the story by saying she refused to do the teachers work, because she does in fact do the work on the board for the class. Also, you mention that this and other stories demonstrate doing something positive to become cool, however my story doesn't really fit this mold. She isn't doing anything bad, but she isn't doing anything particularly positive either. I would rethink using this piece of evidence for this argument.
2- I think that you should expand your drug argument. There are drugs less severe and more common drugs that are seen as much cooler than heroin that you could discuss. Take marijuana for example, which is used much more frequent and is exposed to teens at a much younger age and is more accepted. Also, heroin is too well known to be harmful to be as relevant.
3- On a side not, some of your post appears in a different font than the rest of it, and while I believe it was intentional in the intro, it's use in the last few paragraphs was confusing.

Kate-
We use cool as a way to hide our true selves to try and blend in. Should we turn to the media, we can see many examples of this. Take for example the movie "The New Guy". In this movie, protagonist Dizzy is a nerd, simply put. However, he gets embarrassed horribly on the first day of his senior year and is put on meds, eventually going crazy and sent to jail where he is shown the light that he needs to reinvent himself or "revamp". He then creates a new identity for a new school and becomes the coolest kid and gets the hot cheerleader. This movie shows in perfect fashion the ways that one will hide who they truly are to blend in and be cool.
1- I think that you could expand your argument on hair. You state what it is very clearly, however you don't seem to draw much of a conclusion from it, at least not immediately where it would make logical sense for flow.
2- Some of your spacing is really weird, parts of the paragraphs start on new lines randomly and it makes it a little distracting to follow those parts.
3- I agree with Andy, I think you could draw an interesting conclusion between masks and how we throw our insecurities onto them. What would this say about cool? Is cool really just the worst part of yourself? Is it the best?

Monday, November 23, 2009

HW 25- Story Comments and Analysis

Part 1- Comments

Hannah-

Hannah, I liked your story. I felt like it was interesting to see how the girl thought she was cool and yet she tried to act cooler despite this. The boy complementing the girl and saving her is also pretty cool and I liked how you added in details such as the smell of his jacket.

Maggie-

Maggie, I like the simplicity of your story. Though you use no dialogue, you manage to convey a very surreal atmosphere that is like a waiting room of a hospital, with small talk and frantic personalities. I like how you convey cool by seeing through other people's fake faces and this is a common thread everybody is aware but rarely do you see this in the real world, which I think helped to add to the tone of the piece.

Rachel-

Rachel, I thought it was interesting that you pointed out bluntly what made her cool. I think that your story worked best when you led the reader to draw their own conclusions and left the girl a mystery. By having her ignore others and dismiss their opinions of her, I think that you made her seem like her own person, an individual, which is always cool. Adding in the copycats at the end was a nice touch to show the social impact she was having on the community and that others also thought she was cool.

Marco-

Marco, I found your story to really stand out amongst many of the ones I have read. Your more offensive look on what cool is helps to show that in fact, the narrator is the cool person, not those observed. By not selling out to some corporation to buy what's cool, you show that being true to who you are is cool. This is well supported by your talk of jocks and nerds and geeks, which I think was nice touch to show how cool is not one defined term and is different amongst different people.

Beatrice-

Beatrice, I found your story to be quite interesting. By having the girl simply isolate herself from everybody else, she has her individuality and that makes her much cooler than those around her who can't even work up the courage to talk to her. Music is very important here, because by ending and starting the story with music you show that Tatum is off in her own world, but a world of uncertainty and I think that this is an interesting thing to think about when one thinks of cool, how we can doubt ourselves or be unsure and still be cool. Good job.

Part 2- Analysis

Cool is not store bought, despite what the media would have you believe. Every story I read and even the one I wrote came to the realization that cool was in the way one acted, in their attitude. I think that this is a very key conclusion to come to, although it is a rather simple and obvious conclusion. If cool was truly store bought, why wasn't everybody cool? And if everybody did buy "cool" from the store, would it still be cool to have "cool"? No, cool is best when it comes from inside a person and they act like they don't care about anybody's opinion of themselves.
These stories all had another common theme amongst 4 of them, somewhat 5 depending on how you interpret Marco's story. This theme is that even if cool is not store bought, it can be enhanced. By having "cool" headphones or cool "jeans", somebody can have a "look" that makes them cooler. In the case of Hannah's story, the cool character fell into the category of bad boy/ladies man, even if not intentional. By having the "cool" character smooth talk and save the girl, he was also the typical hero of literature, saving the helpless damsel in distress. This is often seen as cool in many different representations. As for Rachel's story, by having the "cool" jeans and boots, the character was cool because she had copycats. While she was cool in addition to this, she was extra cool because of this.
I found it interesting that in none of the stories was anybody older cooler. I know the assignment was to discuss somebody around 17 years old who was cool, but nobody had any real interactions with older generations and none had anybody cool that was older than the protagonist. I think that while accidental, this does give insight in that people don't find older generations to be particularly cool. This is a pretty mainstream perspective and shows the effects of cool and the boundaries because nobody can maintain cool forever and nobody is cool in everybody's eyes, which connects to Marco's story about different groups of cool. All in all, cool is not all encompassing and is not eternal, but just something to fill the time between the actual meaningful activities of life.

Wednesday, November 4, 2009

HW 19- Big Paper 1, Suggestions

Maggie-

Maggie, I am very disappointed... only an introduction? You could have just used your outline even, that was a good length and had a depth to it that I'm sure you could have easily re-worked into a paper, much like I did with mine. Working with what you have though, I have the following to say:
For your intro, I think you have a solid start. You mention a few aspects of technology that can be flushed out to accomplish your thesis that digital-representational-devices are addicting. I think that with what I read of your outline that you have good points, but I almost feel that for an introduction paragraph you throw too many of them in there. An intro doesn't need to go into detail about your internet habits and it doesn't need the quantity of examples you have provided so early on. I almost feel like you are rushing into this and that your arguments might fall flat because you threw their legs out before you got to their bodies. You are also a bit jumpy structurally and I feel like you can smooth this out a bit or at least make the examples transition smoother if you decide to keep them. On a last note, I think that you should copy this into word for some grammatical help, because some of the wording felt funky and it seemed to end rashly.
If these suggestions seem to be harsh, keep in mind I had to correct an entire paper's worth of problems from one paragraph, so every minute detail is emphasized. I think that you have a good paper on the way with what I know about your previous postings and I look forward to seeing what you provide.
Best of luck,

Henry

Monday, November 2, 2009

HW 17- Outline Suggestions

Maggie-

Points on your paper according to where they appear:

Thesis: I think your thesis is clear and concise and you just need to tidy up the Carrie and Henry examples you put with it.

Argument 1: I like your argument here, it is something that I have seen you talk about before in other blogs so I know that you have more to say than what you put here. I think that you need to clarify your example here with Lauren, specify how you had the conversation and if it included anything else. And would talking about how the conversation or other conversations on AIM and Facebook are always casual contradict the statement because it's a deeper topic? Also, you stray a bit too much for one argument, you range from AIM to Facebook to photos and other features of these sites, you should focus instead on just AIM and Facebook, if not just one.

Argument 2: I like how you start off by talking about the interview we did earlier in the unit, but I think that you should do more than just say (Interview) when you refer to it, because not everybody will understand the context. You do however stray quite far away from the main topic you start the paragraph with, that computers are efficient. You can still use most of your examples here, but you need to connect them back to the main point otherwise it makes them seem like random ramblings on technology. You should also do this when connecting to Feed, show the parallels between the book and our world so that it is clear what you are trying to get the reader to think about.

Argument 3: I really like the way you proposed your idea here through the examples provided. I think that all of these examples are relevant and could use a little expansion or connection to really make it work. You spend twice as much time developing Wall-E as any of your other examples, and they falter a bit as a result.

Conclusion: I think this is a fine conclusion, but you can fluff it out a bit to make it sound a bit more approachable and appealing to accept.

Overall: I think that you have a lot of great ideas here in your outline and I am genuinely interested in what you have to say in these postings that will come up. I think that in order for these to become really relevant and exciting you really need to smooth things together more so that it has flow. The way you currently propose your points is very "blurty", by this I mean you just throw stuff out there but there is no flow. If you can both expand on your points and get them to flow together more you will have a tremendous paper that everybody should read.